Skip to main content

IntegrityStar, November 2026 edition

 

As mentioned in our March 2026 edition, not all reports submitted to the UCF IntegrityLine require an investigation. Sometimes the report contains a question seeking guidance or additional resources. In this edition’s Case Corner, we share an inquiry that was submitted regarding workplace civility.

 

Background

An employee submitted a UCF IntegrityLine report expressing concerns that the tone and content of an email exchange they had with a colleague may have crossed the line of professionalism in the workplace. The employee shared a redacted copy of the email exchange and asked whether the communication would be considered bullying.

 

Review and Resolution

After reviewing the email exchange, investigators found the communication to be very direct but not unprofessional. This outcome was shared with the employee along with information on how to navigate the interpretation of written communications. Investigators also took the opportunity to provide guidance on workplace bullying and shared information on how to determine when communications cross the line from being a direct communication to bullying. As explained to the employee, a communication that is perceived as abrupt, critical, or discourteous does not necessarily constitute bullying or other prohibited conduct. When assessing workplace interactions, it is important to consider the nature and frequency of the conduct, whether there is an ongoing pattern, the circumstances surrounding the interactions, and the impact on the workplace. Conduct that may be appropriate in one context can be inappropriate in another, particularly when the communication becomes persistent, unreasonable, or demeaning.

This report highlighted a common challenge with electronic communication: written messages can sometimes be interpreted differently than intended because they lack the tone and nonverbal cues present in face-to-face conversations. Investigators encouraged the employee to consider the broader context of their workplace interactions and, if appropriate, to address any remaining workplace concerns through established university resources such as Human Resources, leadership, and the University Ombuds Office.

This Case Corner illustrates an example of how the IntegrityLine served as a resource for ethical questions or dilemmas allowing an opportunity to provide guidance and resources.